- November 15, 2024
- 7:08 pm
- Israel
Israel is discussing the idea of transferring captured Russian weapons seized by the IDF to Ukraine. Despite for lack of official confirmationthis step seems logical and has important symbolic meaning.
Information appeared in the Israeli mediathat on November 14, 2024, Channel 12 journalist Yaron Avraham spoke about the bill put forward by Sharen Askel. This the bill provides for the transfer of Russian-made captured weapons that the Israeli army seizes in Lebanon, the Gaza Strip and the Palestinian territories to the Ukrainian army. Now these weapons are being destroyed, but the initiative proposes to use them to help Ukraine.
The bill was introduced before Askel took office as deputy foreign minister and joined the government. As Abraham explained, now Askel cannot independently promote this proposal. Her colleague in the Likud party, Dan Iluz, will be involved in its implementation. The journalist also noted that the bill “could complicate Israel’s relations with Putin.”
The initiative of Knesset member Sharen Askel to transfer Russian weapons seized by the IDF to Ukraine caused lively discussions.
Although there is no official confirmation yet, the idea itself seems logical, given the circumstances and geopolitical context.
We have already written about captured Russian weapons from the IDF, for example:
October 16, 2024 — Russian weapons were found in Hezbollah's possession—and have they already summoned the Russian ambassador along with the military attaché to give an explanation?
October 17, 2024 — Netanyahu: “We found a large number of the most modern Russian weapons at Hezbollah” – so what?
June 8, 2024 — The Kremlin said that it could transfer weapons against the United States (and its allies) to international terrorists – to whom?
October 16, 2023 — Russian weapons in the service of Hamas – the security service showed arsenals intercepted from militants during the invasion of Israel
The essence of the initiative: what does Sharen Askel offer?
The bill involves the transfer of captured Russian weapons to the Ukrainian army. These weapons were recovered by the Israeli army during operations:
- In Lebanon – Hezbollah militants;
- In the Gaza Strip – Palestinian terrorists;
- In Judea and Samaria – when suppressing combat cells.
At the moment, such weapons are either destroyed or remain in warehouses. Askel's proposal aims to ensure that these weapons are used against their original manufacturer, Russia.
“This is logical, because the IDF is unfamiliar with this weapon, and it is not used in the Israeli army. Ukraine will be able to use it effectively,” experts say.
What are the Israeli media saying?
Journalist Yaron Abraham of Channel 12 revealed details of the bill, noting that it was put forward shortly before Sharen Askel was sworn in as deputy foreign minister.
Since Askel cannot promote the bill, her Likud colleague, MP Dan Iluz, is doing this.
Why is this proposal controversial?
The transfer of weapons to Ukraine is not only a military issue, but also a diplomatic step that could affect Israel's relations with Russia.
Arguments of supporters
- Ukraine support:
Israel demonstrates its solidarity with the Ukrainian people in their fight against Russian aggression.
- Efficient use of resources:
The captured weapons, which are now being destroyed, could bring real benefits.
- Symbolic gesture:
The transfer of Russian weapons to Ukraine will emphasize the independence of Israeli foreign policy.
Arguments of opponents
- Risks for relations with Russia:
Moscow may perceive this as a direct threat and reconsider its coordination with Israel in Syria.
- Involvement in conflict:
Israel traditionally tries to maintain neutrality in the war between Russia and Ukraine.
- Internal disagreements:
Not all Israelis support active involvement in the Ukrainian conflict.
What weapons are they planning to transfer?
Captured weapons include:
| Weapon type | Origin | Where captured |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-tank missiles “Kornet” | Russia | Lebanon, Gaza Strip |
| Almaz missiles | Iran (copy of Spike) | Lebanon, deliveries via Syria |
Why are these weapons not used by the IDF?
The Israeli army relies on proven weapons systems of local and Western origin, such as Spike missiles or American Javelin systems. Russian and Iranian weapons do not meet Israeli military standards and require significant integration efforts.
“Given that these weapons reach Israel through hostile sources, they are best used to weaken the aggressor himself,” analysts emphasize.
Historical examples: How did Israel use spoils?
Israel has repeatedly found use for captured weapons:
- 1967 — Soviet T-55 tanks, after modernization, were included in the IDF.
- 1980s — Lebanese warehouses replenished Israeli arms stocks.
- Modernity — Iranian Almaz missiles are being studied to develop new air defense systems.
However, in most cases, weapons were destroyed due to the inability to adapt them.
Why is there no official confirmation yet?
The issue of arms transfer remains at the discussion level. As a member of the government, Sharen Askel cannot independently promote this bill, and its fate now depends on her colleagues in the Knesset.
At the moment there is no official information about the decision. However, the idea itself is being actively discussed in political and military circles in Israel.
This is logical: opinion NAnews
Askel's initiative, although not confirmed, seems rational. The captured weapons have no practical value for Israel, but can become a powerful tool for Ukraine in its fight against aggression.
NAnews Israel News continues to monitor developments and provide detailed coverage of initiatives that may impact Israeli foreign policy.
“It is logical that instead of being destroyed, these weapons will find use where they are really needed,” experts say.
Conclusion:
The initiative to transfer captured weapons to Ukraine is not only a practical, but also a symbolic step. It could strengthen ties with Ukraine, but at the same time complicate relations with Russia. No decision has been made yet, but the idea continues to cause heated debate in Israel.
Leave a comment in Telegram – NAnews channel↓
